Tyler Toffoli Goals Prediction: Under 0.5 vs Sharks — March 18 NHL Pick
Tyler Toffoli's goals prop is a sharp Under play on tonight's NHL slate. The Edmonton Oilers face the San Jose Sharks on March 18, and our model projects the veteran winger to fall short of the 0.5-goal line. Here's why we're backing the Under at -400 odds.
Tyler Toffoli Stats & Recent Form
Toffoli has cooled significantly over his last five games, averaging just 0.4 goals per contest with only two goals in that stretch. The 34-year-old has seen a dip in both shot volume and quality scoring chances, particularly against teams with structured defensive systems like San Jose. His ice time has remained steady around 16-17 minutes per game, but his finishing has regressed from earlier in the season when he was more consistently beating goaltenders.
Matchup Analysis: Edmonton vs San Jose
San Jose ranks 12th in the league in goals against per game at 2.89, and more importantly, they've tightened their penalty kill to 82.5% over the last 10 games. The Sharks' defensively responsible approach limits high-danger chances for opposing forwards, and Toffoli hasn't been the type of volume shooter who can beat a solid goaltender through sheer shot generation. Vegas pricing the Under at -400 reflects a sharply oddsmaker perspective on this matchup dynamic.
Our Toffoli Goals Prop Pick for March 18
We're backing the Under 0.5 Goals at -400. Toffoli's recent scoring drought, combined with San Jose's defensive structure and Toffoli's declining shot metrics, makes this a clear fade on the Over despite the +270 plus-money odds. The risk-reward heavily favors punching the Under ticket here—the Oilers' secondary scorer simply isn't connecting at the rate required to justify betting on him to score against a defense that's locked in down the stretch.
Where to Bet Tyler Toffoli Props Tonight
Ready to act on this pick? Here are your best options:
- DFS Play: Tyler Toffoli is a strong play on DraftKings Pick 6 — enter promo code ONTAP for a deposit bonus.
- Sportsbook: Grab the line at Caesars Sportsbook. First Bet Matched Up to $250 in Bonus Bets.
- Prediction Markets: Trade this Tyler Toffoli prop on Kalshi — the only federally regulated prediction market in the US. No sportsbook needed — use promo code ONTAP.
Always bet responsibly. Must be 18+.