Matthew Schaefer Props Today vs New York Islanders | March 19, 2026
Matthew Schaefer takes the ice for the Ottawa Senators in a matchup against the New York Islanders on March 19, 2026. The defenseman has been a steady contributor on the Senators' blue line this season, bringing reliable defensive play and occasional offensive upside from the back end. With the Islanders presenting a defensive-minded opponent, Schaefer's prop slate offers some interesting angles worth exploring. His recent form and usage patterns will be critical in determining whether he can surpass or fall short of today's betting lines.
Assists Prop: 0.5 Assists | Over +105 / Under -135
Schaefer's assists line sits at 0.5, with the Under positioned as the heavy favorite at -135 juice. This reflects the reality that most defensemen don't record assists on a nightly basis, and Schaefer, while capable, isn't among the league's elite point-producing blueliners. Over his recent stretch, he's been involved in the offensive play but hasn't consistently generated multiple assists per game. The Islanders' defensive structure will also limit high-danger scoring chances that typically lead to defensive assists.
The Over at +105 offers modest value if you believe Schaefer will be heavily utilized in the offensive zone during power plays or extended offensive possession. However, the weight of evidence suggests the Under is the safer play here. Schaefer would need to both touch the puck on multiple scoring plays and have those plays result in goals, which is a high bar against an Islanders team known for defensive discipline.
Recommendation: Under 0.5 Assists
Points Prop: 0.5 Points | Over -130 / Under +100
The Points line flips the script compared to the Assists prop, with the Over favored at -130. This makes sense mathematically, as points include both goals and assists, providing multiple pathways to hit the Over. Schaefer has shown flashes of offensive capability this season, and while he's not a high-volume scorer, he's capable of putting up the occasional point. The -130 juice suggests sportsbooks see roughly a 56-57% probability of him recording at least one point.
Against an Islanders team that plays a structured but not suffocating defensive system, Schaefer should see reasonable ice time and opportunity to contribute offensively, particularly on the power play. Even defensemen with modest offensive output typically record 0.5+ points in roughly half their games across a full season. The favorable odds on the Over, combined with Schaefer's recent activity and today's matchup dynamics, tilt the scale toward expecting at least one point from the veteran blueliner.
Recommendation: Over 0.5 Points
Best Bet Today: Over 0.5 Points
The Over on Schaefer's Points prop at -130 represents the strongest play on his slate today. While the Assists prop leans Under due to the difficulty in recording multiple assists, the Points prop benefits from a lower threshold and multiple ways to cross it. Schaefer's ice time allocation, power play opportunities, and the Islanders' defensive profile all suggest he has a legitimate shot at reaching one point. The -130 odds are fair value for a proposition where the underlying probability exceeds sportsbook assumptions. Lock in the Over and look for Schaefer to contribute his way to a winning ticket.
Where to Bet Matthew Schaefer Props Today
- DFS: DraftKings Pick 6 — Deposit $5, Get $25 in Bonus Instantly + Up to 100% Winning Boost — enter code ONTAP
- Sportsbook: Novig — Spend $5, Get $50 in Novig Tokens — bet at true odds with zero vig
- Prediction Markets: Trade Matthew Schaefer's props on Kalshi — the only federally regulated prediction market in the US — use promo code ONTAP to get a FREE $10.
Always bet responsibly. Must be 18+. This article was created with AI assistance.