John Tavares Goals Prediction: Under 0.5 vs Islanders — March 17 NHL Pick
John Tavares' goals prop is a sharp Under play on Tuesday night's NHL slate. The Toronto Maple Leafs captain returns to face his former team, the New York Islanders, on March 17, and our model projects he'll fall short of the 0.5 goal line. The -280 odds reflect the difficulty of getting on the board, and the data backs a defensive approach here.
John Tavares Stats & Recent Form
Tavares has been inconsistent over his last five games, averaging 2.2 shots on goal per contest with just one goal in that stretch. The 35-year-old center remains a reliable playmaker but has cooled considerably in the scoring department since mid-February. His goal-scoring pace has dipped to roughly 0.35 goals per game over the past 15 contests, well below his season average. Against divisional opponents specifically, Tavares has scored in just 2 of his last 8 matchups.
Matchup Analysis: Toronto Maple Leafs vs New York Islanders
The Islanders rank 12th in goals-against per game but have tightened their defensive structure significantly in recent weeks, holding opponents to 2.1 goals per game over their last 10 outings. New York's secondary scoring has forced them to play a more conservative, trap-heavy system that limits high-danger chances for opposing forwards. Additionally, the emotional weight of Tavares facing his former franchise often disrupts his rhythm—he's historically underperformed in these revenge-type matchups.
Our Tavares Goals Prop Pick for March 17
We're backing the Under 0.5 Goals at -280. Tavares has cooled at the worst possible time, his matchup disadvantage is real against an Islanders team playing suffocating defense, and the odds reflect smart market pricing. This John Tavares prop prediction aligns with Kalshi John Tavares goal-scoring market sentiment. Look for him to rack up assists rather than goals—a safer outcome for Under bettors targeting NHL props on March 17.
Where to Bet John Tavares Props Tonight
Ready to act on this pick? Here are your best options:
- DFS Play: John Tavares is a strong play on Underdog Fantasy — enter promo code ONTAP for a deposit bonus.
- Sportsbook: Grab the line at Caesars Sportsbook. First Bet Matched Up to $250 in Bonus Bets.
- Prediction Markets: Trade this John Tavares prop on Kalshi — the only federally regulated prediction market in the US. No sportsbook needed — use promo code ONTAP.
Always bet responsibly. Must be 18+.